Why Diets Keep Failing You (and What Actually Works)
- Brooke Young
- Dec 18, 2025
- 4 min read
Let’s Be Honest: How Many Diets Have You Tried?
Let’s start here, how many diets have you jumped into with full motivation, only to fall off weeks later?
Keto. Whole30. Juice cleanses. Cutting carbs. Cutting sugar. Cutting everything that makes food enjoyable.
Most “diets” fail for one simple reason: they’re built on restriction, not sustainability.
They turn food into the enemy and make the process so miserable that quitting feels inevitable.
And then when the weight comes back (because it almost always does), we blame ourselves instead of the system.
Here’s the truth no one wants to say out loud:
👉 Fat loss does not have to be miserable.
👉 Food is meant to be enjoyed.
👉 You don’t need another diet....you need a better approach.
Yes… losing fat can be enjoyable. And no, that’s not just a motivational quote, this is backed by real, sustainable habits.
Because guess what!?
THIS IS WHAT WORKED FOR ME! I am 80+lbs down and keeping it off FOR GOOD!
Why Diet Culture Keeps Us Stuck
As a society, we tend to do everything in excess.
Excess food, excess stress, excess work, excess restriction.
So we swing between two extremes:
Overindulging
Then over-restricting to “fix it”
That cycle is exactly how most people end up stuck for years, bouncing between fad diets while trying to reclaim a body they once had.
The problem isn’t willpower.
The problem is that no one taught you how to eat, move, and live in a way that actually lasts.
That’s what this blog is about.
Below are the real principles I used with MYSELF and with my clients... the ones that lead to fat loss and long-term lifestyle change.
The Foundations of Sustainable Weight Loss
1. Set Clear, Realistic Goals
Before anything else, we need to redefine what “healthy” actually means.
If your only measure of success is the number on the scale, you’re missing the bigger picture.
Instead, ask yourself:
Do I want more energy?
Do I want to feel stronger?
Do I want better sleep?
Do I want confidence in my own skin?
Yes, weight loss can be part of the goal, but it shouldn’t be the only one.
Sustainable fat loss happens when you focus on overall well-being, not perfection. Realistic progress looks like:
1–2 pounds per week
Strength gains
Improved habits
Better consistency
Small, achievable milestones build momentum. That momentum is what keeps people going.
2. Understand Your Current Habits (Awareness Comes First)
You can’t change what you’re not aware of.
Before adjusting calories or workouts, I want people to understand their current patterns.
That means:
Tracking food for a short period (MyFitnessPal is my go-to)
Noticing emotional eating triggers
Paying attention to weekends, snacking, and portions
This isn’t about judgment... it’s about data.
We also look at:
Daily movement and step count
Structured workouts (or lack of them)
Sleep quality
Stress levels
Most people underestimate how much sleep and stress affect hunger, cravings, and fat loss.
Once you see the full picture, the path forward becomes much clearer.
3. Start Small (This Is Where Most People Get It Wrong)
The biggest mistake I see? Trying to change everything at once.
That’s a fast track to burnout.
Instead, sustainable change comes from small, intentional adjustments, like:
Slightly reducing portion sizes
Adding more protein to meals
Swapping one snack per day
Drinking more water
Increasing daily steps
One habit at a time.
And here’s the key:
👉 We focus on adding nutritious foods, not removing the foods you love.
Restriction creates rebellion. Balance creates consistency.
4. The 80/20 Rule: The Sweet Spot
This is one of the most powerful mindset shifts you can make.
Eat nutrient-dense, whole foods about 80% of the time.
Enjoy your favorite foods, the ones that make life enjoyable, about 20% of the time.
This approach:
Allows flexibility
Reduces guilt
Makes social events possible
Keeps you consistent long-term
You can lose fat and enjoy dinners out, vacations, and treats.
That’s how this becomes a lifestyle instead of a temporary phase.
5. Stay Active in a Way You Can Sustain
Exercise should enhance your life... not punish you for eating.
Movement matters, but it doesn’t have to be extreme.
The goal is consistency, not exhaustion.
This can include:
Walking
Strength training
Group fitness
Dancing
Any activity you genuinely enjoy
General guidelines:
~150 minutes of moderate movement per week
Strength training at least 2x per week
More daily movement (steps, stairs, walks after meals)
Strength training, in particular, is a game-changer for fat loss, metabolism, and confidence.
6. Rest and Recovery Are Non-Negotiable
You cannot out-train poor sleep.
Lack of rest increases hunger hormones, cravings, and stress... making fat loss significantly harder.
Prioritize:
7–9 hours of sleep per night
Rest days when needed
Recovery as part of the plan, not a reward
Progress happens when your body is supported, not run into the ground.
BONUS: Consistency Over Perfection
This is where real success happens.
You will have days that aren’t perfect.
You will eat off-plan.
You will miss workouts.
None of that ruins your progress.
What does matter is what you do next.
Fat loss is about patterns over time, not single days.
Track more than just the scale:
How your clothes fit
Energy levels
Strength gains
Sleep quality
Mood and confidence
Always remember:
👉 This takes time.
👉 You didn’t get here overnight.
👉 You won’t change overnight either.
But if you stay consistent?
Everything changes.
We don’t quit.




Comments